A very big problem on the political left is our willingness and readiness to set up our very own with much greater intensity and energy than to the other side.
The all-or-nothing attitude. The excommunication of imperfect allies. The moral certainty required to define an enemy. A new form of puritanism defined by sharp contrasts: either you are with us or against us.
We now live in Carl Schmitt’s world. Schmitt, that Nazi legal thinker who argued that politics begins with the definition of an enemy. Schmitt, the Nazi thinker who despised the pluralism that institutions bring about. Schmitt, the Nazi scholar who made notions of human rights and liberal pluralism suspect.
It feels like 1930 in Weinmar Republic. After the coalition of parties collapsed in 1930, the Social Democratic Party approached the Communist Party (KPD) to form a new coalition, but the more radical KPD turned them down, believing them to be a greater enemy than the Nazis themselves. This internal division between political allies in a larger context of unemployment and the disillusion with markets (the Great Depression in America had just begun), gave rise to a Führer.
Fast forward to a few decades. The pluralism that defined liberal democratic societies after the Second World War in the West is now challenged by a new wave of illiberalism from both the left and the right. On the right, the policing of individuals by macho strongmen. On the left, the policing of thought by intellectual puritans.
No wonder so many of our youth are turned off by this new form of ideological puritanism and finding a more welcoming place with Andrew Tate, Jordan Petterson, Joe Rogan, and similar “gateway drugs” to the far-right manosphere.
Authoritarianism is brought about by the atomization of society. Like the Communists preferring to work with the Nazis before with the Socialists, the political left in America is falling apart. We are all becoming atoms with our own views confirmed in our own little devices.
As the public Agora burns down, public discourse corrodes. The principle of charity, a virtue once championed by the political left, is giving way to a new form of self-righteousness and moral superiority that once defined the religious right.
Without the inclusive pluralism, the left will concede to the death of democracy.